England suffered a rare home defeat, losing 1-0 to Japan as Brighton winger Kaoru Mitoma's 23rd-minute strike secured the Samurai Blue's first-ever win over the Three Lions. Thomas Tuchel's rotated side looked flat and disjointed, intensifying questions over Cole Palmer's form, the lack of a clear Kane deputy and the XI Tuchel will take to the World Cup.
England stunned by historic Japan victory
England lost 1-0 at home to Japan in a final World Cup warm-up, a first-ever defeat by the Samurai Blue and the Three Lions' first reverse since June. Kaoru Mitoma finished a slick counter-attack in the 23rd minute, exploiting a turnover and clinical finishing to beat Jordan Pickford — the first goal Pickford has conceded in an England shirt since October 2024.
How the goal came and what it revealed
Japan's opener was the product of quick, incisive passing and movement that exposed England's reluctance to press high as a unit. The goal stemmed from a loose pass in midfield and a well-executed transition, underlining England's vulnerability in moments of turnover. For a match intended as a tougher test than the stoppage-time penalty draw with Uruguay, Japan delivered and exposed tactical and personnel issues.
Tuchel's selection signals a near-final starting XI
Thomas Tuchel made 10 changes from the Uruguay friendly, effectively using these friendlies to split his extended squad. The line-up selection suggested Tuchel has already settled nine of the 11 starters likely to face Croatia in the World Cup opener — names such as Jordan Pickford, Marc Guehi and Elliot Anderson emerged with clear paths to starting roles, while Lewis Hall looks set as first-choice left-back.
Which positions remain open
The most genuine selection debates now concern the left wing and the No.10 role. Marcus Rashford competes with Anthony Gordon and Morgan Rogers for the wide berth, while the creative ten is contested by Cole Palmer, Jude Bellingham, Phil Foden and Rogers. Bellingham's energy and influence make him the frontrunner in this writer's estimation, but Tuchel will demand clearer evidence from Palmer and others before finalising plans.
Cole Palmer — decline or bad night?
Once viewed as England's creative heir after a standout Euro final and stellar club season, Palmer was anonymous here. He registered zero successful dribbles, no shots on target, a single touch in the box and notably lost possession leading to the goal. Limited minutes this season due to injury partly explain rustiness, but performance levels must rise quickly if he is to displace Bellingham or Foden in the engine room.
The Harry Kane dilemma remains unresolved
With Ollie Watkins omitted and both Dominic Solanke and Calvert-Lewin failing to convince as reliable deputies, Tuchel tested Phil Foden as a false nine — a move that highlighted the absence of a natural backup to Harry Kane. Kane cannot be expected to play every minute of a major tournament; England still lack a clear, complementary alternative who can replicate Kane's hold-up and finishing. This is an urgent strategic puzzle for Tuchel heading into the final squad selection phase.
Japan's claim: a team arriving in form
Japan offered the kind of cohesive, high-tempo football admired across Asia and Europe — rapid passing, intelligent transitions and genuine attacking threat. Back-to-back results, including this victory and a recent win at Hampden Park over Scotland, suggest this Japan group may be the most accomplished Samurai Blue side in recent memory. Their performance here will give them both confidence and tactical ammunition for the World Cup.
What this means for Tuchel and England
This defeat crystallises several immediate priorities: identifying a functional substitute for Kane, deciding whether Palmer can regain form in time, and tightening defensive and transitional moments that allowed Japan to flourish. Tuchel must also weigh the benefit of giving fringe players minutes against the need for cohesion among his likely starters. Expect targeted training adjustments and last-minute selection tests before the provisional squad is announced.
Next steps
England head into the final weeks before the tournament with questions that are solvable but pressing.
Club form and fitness will dictate several late calls; Tuchel's next moves should prioritise a reliable central striker plan, sharper link-up play between midfield and attack, and restoring the tempo England fans expect.
Italy miss out on World Cup again after Bosnia and Herzegovina’s shootout triumph
For Japan, this result confirms they arrive at the World Cup with belief and a tactical blueprint that can trouble any opponent.
Express
